www.expressindia.com - Weather | Horoscope | Stocks | RSS
expressindia web city
HomeBlogsCricketAstrology TendersClassifieds Reader Comments Hotels
Sign In / Register | Archive
Expressindia » Story

Don't brand Australia racist; give time to act, say Indians

Font Size

Agencies

Posted: May 31, 2009 at 1100 hrs IST

Melbourne As Australian authorities face flak over a series of attacks on Indian students, leading members of the community spoke out against branding the country as ‘racist’ and said the Government should be given some time to resolve the problem.

At the same time, they expressed their deep concern over the security issues of Indian students.

Insisting that Australia was not a ‘racist’ country and all attacks were not racist in nature, Sydney-based cardiologist Yadu Singh said "We believe that this is not the correct picture of the unfortunate events."

"Most of the attacks are what we call 'opportunistic attacks' and due to the impression by the criminal elements about our students being the easy target for various reasons," Singh said.

Indian-origin CEO of leading company Primus, Ravi Bhatia, who took part in a peace rally here, said "Australia is a very open and tolerant society. It is a fun-loving country.

"There are many examples of highly successful members in the Indian community. Just like any other society, there are small minority of miscreants and malcontents," he said.

"Voice of Indian students have been heard at the highest level of the country. I would request them to give Government time to address grievances," Bhatia said.

Indian students hold rally in Australia, protest attacks

Shaken by a wave of racial assaults, thousands of Indian students chanting 'Bharat Mata Ki Jai' on Sunday rallied here demanding justice for victims of recent attacks as Australia scrambled to contain the rising anger and frustration within the community.

The 'peace rally' organised by bodies like Federation of Indian Students in Australia (FISA) and National Union of Students kicked off from outside the Royal Melbourne Hospital, where 25-year-old Shravan Kumar is in a critical condition after being stabbed with a screwdriver by a group of teens on Sunday last.

Kumar, who had slipped into coma after being stabbed, was "out of danger", but still critical, said a leading community member who visited him at the hospital. "He (Kumar) has come out of coma and moved his hands," said T J Rao, also a former Consul General of India in Melbourne who too participated in the rally. "Kumar is out of life support, but doctors are still not very sure about his full recovery," he said.

The marchers numbering over 5,000 walked down to the Victorian Parliament House on Spring street, holding placards with slogans like 'We want Justice', 'We are the Economy Builders' and 'End Racist Attacks'. They also chanted 'Bharat

Mata Ki Jai'.

FISA founder Gautam Gupta, who led the rally, said "we believe in 'Gandhigiri'" and peaceful ways to present the demands of the student community. The students had hoped to hand over their demands' list to the lawmakers, but it could not be materialised. Their demands included a multicultural police force for Victoria, which houses 47,000 of the 95,000 Indian student community in Australia. They also demanded that crime statistics be made public and sought racial tolerance and awareness, and advertising campaign to welcome international students, highlighting their contribution to the Australian economy.

Facing flak over the spate of racial assaults, Australia government said it was doing everything it can to prevent further attacks on the community.

"We're doing everything that we can, both with the Indian community in Australia and India itself ... but also working very closely with the relevant state authorities," Australian Foreign Minister Stephen Smith was quoted as saying.

He assured the community that the Australian authorities are trying to bring the attackers to justice and ensure a safe environment for all international students. Apart from Shravan Kumar, the Indian students attacked recently included Baljinder Singh, who has been discharged from hospital after being stabbed by two attackers, and Rajesh Kumar, who suffered 30 per cent burns after a petrol bomb was hurled at him in his home in Sydney.

In a bid to assuage the feelings of the Indian community here, Australia's first Asia-born Cabinet minister said that racism in this country was confined to "a minority of people" with extreme views. "On the whole I think Australians are tolerant," Malaysia-born Penny Wong, Federal Climate Change Minister, was quoted as saying by AAP. "It is a minority of people in Australia who hold those sort of extreme and intolerant views."

FISA leader Gupta said the massive rally of the students proved that they were not "soft targets" and the situation may get out of hands if the community was attacked again. Gupta expressed confidence that the Australian government would take some action now and punish the perpetrators of the attacks.

Some leading community members, including Australian Telco company Iprimus CEO Ravi Bhatia, also participated in the rally, apart from the state opposition leader Ted Baillieu.

State police personnel in large number were deputed to maintain law and order during the event, which went off peacefully. Traffic was diverted from Spring street, which was blocked for vehicles, during the rally which ended with a candle light vigil.

According to the Australian Associated Press (AAP), there were three arrests during the event. However it did not elaborate. India's Consul General in Melbourne Anita Nayar said she had "no official confirmation" on the arrests. "There were apparently two rallies, one was a 'peace rally' that took off from Royal Melbourne Hospital to Parliament that was later dispersed and other was at Federation Square that remained there," she said. FISA yesterday said the peace rally was being organized in response to the growing anger in the Indian community against increasing hate crimes. "The purpose is to create awareness about an increasing number of hate crimes within the state (of Victoria) and to promote racial harmony and peace," FISA had said in a statement.

Discuss this story on expressindia forums
Post Comments
Name* Email ID*
Subject* Country*
Message*
Characters remaining
 
TERMS OF USE: The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
Insurance Fraud by Patrick on 25 Aug 2011

Rajesh Kumar was not attacked at all you idiots he was burning his own car in an attempt to claim fraudulent money and when he accidently burnt himself in the process he tried to cover it up by blaming "racist australians" tried to set him on fire STOP TWISTING THE FACTS AROUND IN YOUR OWN ANTI AUSTRALIAN PROPAGANDA YOU IDIOTS YOU ARE A BUNCH OF LIARS AND HYPOCRITES!!!

Australains racists against Indians by Rusty Ryan on 21 Dec 2010

I'm from Singapore and I'm Indian. Grew up in Singapore all my life and studied in Aus for a while as well. Aussies are not racist!! Its all those obnoxious Indians coming from rich families from India who are the source. They are rude, arrogant, behave badly, think they're God's gift to the world. I've seen it in Aus, I've seen it in Singapore. Really obnoxious bunch. And some of em smell really bad as well. Why don't you all look at yourselves first before blaming others. I've seen how the bunch of you behave in trains and busses, making a hell of a lot of noise and a nuisance of yourselves. If you think Aussies are racist, good!! Get the hell outta Aus till you learn how to behave!! And stop spoiling the name of Indians all over the world

Racist and Stubborn Australians got it so twisted!!! by Bon Connoisseur on 19 Mar 2010

"Majority of Australians are Racist towards Indians" - this is a fact established by the racial abuses and crimes commited by rogue Australians and their people indirectly supporting all this in different ways. By and large, we can say that Australians probably hate the people of color. We Indians should digest this fact and move on. Our students do not need to go to Australia, if they are not welcome there; because there is no guarantee that the Indian person stepping foot on Australian soil will not be attacked by the racist public over there.

Not all attacks racist by Pathan on 06 Mar 2010

Not all attacks on foreigners are racist. The first attack on Indian student late at night in a park by one person could have been anybody. The Indian student who reported a gang attacking him and burning his car was later found to have torched it himself for insurance. There is some racism in every community - how it is dealt with and whether it is tolerated by the majority surely defines whether a country is racist or not. Australia is multicultural - many more nationalities are welcomed than anywhere else in the world. How could it be that Australia is racist?

The facts by Jonathan on 29 Jan 2010

Racism exists in every country, including India. Extremist political parties have threatened violence against Australian Cricketers, yet I see little or mention by Indians decrying this? India has the most Murders in the world yearly - last year nearly 40,000. Per capita it ranks 26 in murders - Australia 43rd. Last year over 3000 non-indians were murdered in India, In Australia 18 non-Australians were murdered. yes India is larger but on a per capita basis India has a much more serious crime against foreigners issue than most other countries. Violence and racism is a global issue, that should be dealt with. However it offends me when so many India point the finger of blame at foreign countries, when India itself is one of the worst offenders when it comes to violence against foreigners within it's own country.

true belief by truebelief on 15 Jan 2010

it is my opinion that australias econmy is hardly effected by indian students. as a white australian, i would prefer that indian students did not come to australia, in fact, i would prefer no indian even visited here, i have a hard time respecting the indians who come here, especially as india has so much poverty, yet no-one is willing make their country better at home. Stay there, please. our cultures are so different, oh, and leave your cricket team there too.... seriously, as a country with over ten proffesional sports leagues, do u honestly believe any one would care, we didnt play sth africa for 20 yrs, who cares. I also believe most indians spek with emotion rther than their brains, in my experience.

Racial Attacks by Ruchi on 11 Jan 2010

I want to say if Australian gov, is not able to handle racial attacks on Indians. So why they are giving visa to Indian students. In India we can also target Australian people but we are not doing this because we are more civilize than Australian dogs.

We are not racist by Maryanne on 08 Jan 2010

Australia is not a racist country. Indians living here know it too. Australia is a great place to live. Nobody in Australia tolerates this type of violence, whether it be against a white Australian, an Indian or any other race. Murder is murder.

race of betterment by vijay on 04 Jan 2010

i can only comment on this topic that...this type of act should not tolerated more.. more we get develop,more we showing the undeveloped characteristics. govt of the both the country should take a serious action. so that no one career go to spoil. stop saying that give us time and we are doing something. just do it as soon possible. And i also want to say indian citizen who is going to another country make sure some security of urself, nobody going to help its upto u.

racism by mohammed on 22 Oct 2009

we should never go to the racism country anymore, save us from racism .

mr by Philip on 30 Jul 2009

as a white international student in australia, I have seen amongst my non white classmates blatant racism. White australians (and americans, whites in general - tho not all) seem to think they are off more importance than other human beings. Good on indian students for standing up for themselves.One race - THE HUMAN RACE.

"non violence is our way- its really work" by NAUSHAD on 13 Jun 2009

HiIt’s painful to listen about what’s going on in Australia. Different peoples are giving different opinion. Students from Indian origin are facing racism or else. The exact cause I don’t know ,who is the real culprit, may be locals pupils or some government policies or some foreign groups who don’t like India and Australia’s good understanding ,what ever it may be but one thing is clear its not healthy happenings and it must stop immediately. I am worried what had happen in recent past but more than that how it has been presented by media. Its not only affects the carrier of many students who has dream to become a part of this society and have a successful life. Among them some may be rich enough who can travel to another and better country, some may back to India without repent what had happened there but for some it may be difficult to manage this crisis. Economic policies and international relation may also affect. The international charm of Australia in educational point of view also gets affected. It’s not only the government who has to think, how to handle the situation and protect Indians? But all local Aussies must take part in showing their support for Indians, who has left everything and come to you for betterment

"non violence is our way- its really work" by zaffar on 13 Jun 2009

No one is there to listen you.situation is out of hand.lets pray to god

Deliberate attack on Australia by Indian nationalists - fostering paranoia by Melbourner on 10 Jun 2009

How odd that Australians have to defend ourselves against racism and outrageous demands by students who in reality are rarely studying and working with a student visa.What is the evidence of racism and where is the violence that warrants the pulverization of media with such angst against Australia - specifically white people?I have seen no evidence of racism.Most people complain about the current wave of Indian students, but that is because they don't try to fit in. They are very rude - in fact deliberately rude. Nobody else is anything like that, but the same people are making protests saying all Australians are racist and that they are in danger, when neither complaint is reasonable - or even believable!Well there is no way to win if you a typical easy going white person who has never harassed anyone because of what they look like, but who like most people don't appreciate rudeness.I'll just remember not to interact with Indians who show that they want no part of the place they are in.People have learned what Indians can be like when they regard their host country as something to use and abuse.

You're Not Racist at all by Harris Lechqa on 10 Jun 2009

It people like you that are racist. You justify yourself by playing the blame game. You sir, are a racist.

Mr. by Dave on 09 Jun 2009

I can clearly see what makes a terrorists group to emerge. The Indian and Australian government should act fast and ensure this is properly taken care off before a terrorist group or an outsider starts to aid the current activities in Australia. Australia is not the only country requiring International Students, we have a lot of advance nations and better educational options else were. I already see lot of parents discouraging their children even think about Australia. I am sure the Australian government don’t want to lose of big revenue generated from the Indian Students. I would urge Australian and Indian Government to take immediate measure to stop the attacks and there on make good arrangements to ensure this is addressed completely. Else the world should be ready for some serious terror activities starting in Australia. Which might proceed to other nations as well.

australian racism by jaswanth on 09 Jun 2009

After all that happened to Indians still racism continues in Australia and the govt there is giving promises to India even then it does not controlled yet. what a irreresponsible govt it is!

Economic wheels are hard to push by Andrew Smith on 05 Jun 2009

Being a White myself, I am surprised at the ignorance of few whites. Unlike other countries, we don't have a population at an optimal size. But for immigration, the economy contracts. Let us admit our White policy can not be practiced any longer. Migrants from poor countries do not bring headaches but prosperity. To think that a hard working migrant from poor country has stolen a job opportunity from a white is downright silly. We need to be competitive and hardworking as the rest of the world. Why would anybody come to Australia if there is danger to their lives. This is sheer ignorance in today's globalization.

Are we jumping to conclusions? by person who comments on 05 Jun 2009

I got to admit Australiais not a racist country however, there is a definite amount of racism here. The Indians in Australia are not welcolmed here with open arms, there are racial tensions everywhere and most people I know would avoid being next to a first generation indian migrant. I got to admit the these racial attacks would have been dealt differently if it was somewhere else, worse in other words. But we have to admit with this situation this could have been an act not of racism and the could have been many circumstances that could have ignited the situation. Just because they're indian we have come to the conclusion that it is a racist attack. Read the facts know the situation before jumping to conclusions.

White Policy showing its last traces by Andrew Smith on 03 Jun 2009

Being an white, I must be honest. Our country with its official white policy is the culprit in creating this mindset with common white Aussies. We can not deny the contribution made by immigrants to this country in all walks of life. But for them our country would not have been so wealthy. Unfortunately there are few still subscribing to while policy, although the Government has dismantled it. Hopefully they quickly educate themselves to chase away this ill-conceived theories on any non-white communities.

Mrs by Geeta on 03 Jun 2009

Most of the students come to Australia to study and finally settle in OZ,by obtaining PR.Now what has happened to some of the indians is unfortunate and sad.If these students do not wish to continue I am sure their parents would welcome them back to India .But how many of them would want to go back home.There are heaps of Indian students to thrive to get a PR status.Why even bother to get one, when you see Australia as a racist country.There are many occasions when some Australians are themselves bashed for money,due to some bad elements in the society and the government here has laws to tackle them.It would be good if India stops magnifying the issue and creating fear among those who want to pursue their study in OZ

TRUE STATS by Kumar on 03 Jun 2009

Ask an ABO(Aborigine) about the so called "AUSSIE" hehehehe ---Old Boy,UOW

pot...kettle by Ben on 08 Jan 2010

There were more dowry murders in India last year than total murders in Austalia. perhaps we should begin a discussion on the caste system and then see who is rascist?

Mr- Arun Kumar - Read my name correctly by Rohit Banga on 02 Jun 2009

I must say that you have a pretty good sense of humour because you read simple facts as jokes. Regarding your comment about the torch of civilization only burning in India indeed gives a strong impression that you are pretty grown up, mature, sophisticated person blessed with a very open

Time to rethink by outsider on 02 Jun 2009

Indian students started to migrate to OZ land only after OZZY govt. commodify education to a great extent. Students should realize that OZ univs are at satisfactory level. OZZY folks will always be racist and intensity of these racist attacks will be seen more during economic downturn. AND FOREIGNERS WILL BE THE FIRST ONES TO BE AFFECTED IN BAD TIMES.

Let's ask the Dalit what they think by Andrew on 02 Jun 2009

160 million Dalit or "untouchables" live in India.I wonder what they think of the overreaction of the WEALTHY Indian Students in Melbourne...probably not much. I studied with many Indian Students in Melbourne and they were a reclusive lot. Sri Lankans were much friendlier and did not have a mobile phone stuck to their ear 24 hours a day.India needs to get its own affairs in order before accusing Australians of racism. Calling Australians "racist" is a bit rich when 8 x the entire Australian population are Dalit and live in India, and are treated like complete scum.If Indian Students still feel bad about it then don't come to Australia. There are plenty of other fish in the seas to fill your positions at our universities...and perhaps those fish will not be desperate to work illegally here and try to get Permanent Residency the second they enter they country.We don't have a class system in Australia. India can keep their class system and stay away from our shores.

australian shortthinking by archish on 02 Jun 2009

i have proud on amitji.but also suprised with shortthinking of australian.i want to ask them that Do they know wht happen when 90000 or 40-45 thousand student(in future) withdraw their rights of education then what happen with them in such weakeconomic condition. Do they know wht losses accures them due to such attcks on name of racialism? i think that they should now think about this seriously.If they wnt to survive their education industry.

nothing by k on 12 Jun 2009

actually I don't think it'd change much in Australia. other business opportunities would be found as they have been in the past

Australia a Colonial racist country by Dinesh on 02 Jun 2009

Hats off to Mr. Amitab. We stand united if our sons are attacked. Unfortunate our foreign ministry is quiet and not condemining such acts publicly - all officials in foreign ministry are pussys.Indians should boycott Australians and keep them out of the country.Autralia is still a British colony is all manners and I am not surprised at racism practices there.

Latest News

Business

Showbiz

Sports

Let us not be over-sensitive about India, China ties: Krishna

JuD claims Imran Khan will attend its 'Defence of Pakistan' rally

After Guj HC snub, Modi takes Lokayukta row to apex court

Team Anna to kick start its campaign from Haridwar on Jan 21

Have foiled coup attempt to overthrow govt: Bangladesh Army

Jarawa video case: Police arrest 2 persons

Rushdie goes silent on Twitter, no hints about his India visit

More
© 2011 The Indian Express Limited. All rights reserved
Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Express Group | Site Map