
| Font Size |



US Ambassador to India David C Mulford said the dossier contains extensive inputs from the Federal Bureau of Investigation (FBI).
"From what I have seen it is a very credible material. The FBI is cooperating in Mumbai...It is information which tells and gives a very accurate account of what has happened," he told Karan Thapar's programme 'Devil's Advocate'.
Commenting on the Indo-US cooperation in this area, he said the dossier prepared by India extensively used material provided by the FBI. "As far as I see, it (FBI material) was used extensively because the material was same."
Underlining the credible aspect of the dossier, he said, "As far as the FBI is concerned, they do not deal with non-credible material. It is a truly professional organisation supported by absolutely high-tech techniques."
On the Mumbai attacks, Mulford said "there were handlers who were in touch with these people on the ground. It is a serious problem. This act of terrorism came from Pakistan".
When referred to Prime Minister Manmohan Singh's view that "official agencies" of Pakistan could have been involved in the terror strikes, the Ambassador said "I think one needs to be very very careful about making those kinds of allegations unless you have very concrete evidence to that degree of specificity."
The US Ambassador said his country cannot get into "that kind of specificity unless there is some justification for it."
Mulford said that there are a lot of things that tell that "this is a very serious situation. You don't need to know that degree of specificity that you need to compel to pursue the matter."
Emphasising that Pakistan has a "serious problem on its hand", he said "you don't need some kind of a definitive state to know that you have a definite problem on hand."
When referred to Pakistan's virtual rejection of the credibility of evidence within 24 hours after getting it, he said, "Well, I don't think you can cut some quick reaction on the statement of one particular individual. I think it takes some time. You have, after all, a situation where there is a civilian government, a very strong military, a very strong intelligence agency and a media and other players.
"And I think you have to take a view that it is going to take little time to percolate to see what really is the outcome."
He went on to add that "Somebody in denial (mode) doesn't necessarily remain in denial and isn't always on specific point in denial even if they are projecting a sense of denial."
Mulford said "It is complex and you would be mistaken to seize on a statement that is particularly irritating to you or proves a point of some kind to you that are standing back waiting and seeing the effort it is achieving."
Mulford said "It is complex and you would be mistaken to seize on a statement that is particularly irritating to you or proves a point of some kind to you that are standing back waiting and seeing the effort it is achieving."
He said the US view was that the Pakistani government has "responded cooperatively with us".
Insisting that Pakistan is "very concerned" about the situation, the Ambassador said "they (Pakistan) have made some efforts early on to offer a delegation to come to India to cooperate and exchange information which is not being accepted and they have recently agreed to hand over information and cooperate with the government here.
"The question is what is the level of cooperation going to be. How forthcoming is it? Is it enough to satisfy people here of their credibility of the party to cooperate with."
He said one should not "get lost with some of the detail ... because I think we all understand there has to be a level of cooperation to move from here."
Asked how long India should wait for Pakistan to respond, he said "it is not a question of time, although time is important, because to get into a situation where so much time passes, it makes them look uncooperative.
"But you do have to sort of gauge what is happening, what their own situation is and what sort of problems they are facing. And don't forget, the US is in regular touch with them because of its own losses."
The US Ambassador said "if you have to make progress, you have to make some element of cooperation and that means looking at ways to accomplish some minimal levels.
On Pakistan's offer of sending a high-level delegation, he noted that it was made with no detail as to who would be on the delegation and it was never filled out with additional information. "So, I don't think India made a mistake to not take that up because it wasn't going anywhere."
Asked how much time should be given by New Delhi to Islamabad to evaluate evidence, Mulford said it was for the Indian government to decide.
When asked what would happen if there is another terror strike, he said "That will be a very serious matter." Queried whether that could lead to war, he said "I don't know. But it will be a very serious matter.


Discuss this story on expressindia forums
|
|


Mulford "somebody in denial doesnt necessarily remain in denial and isnt always on specific point in denial even if they are projecting a sense of denial." Thats a deep thought. Thanx anyway for crediting us with credibility.
americans are known to take credits. What mulford is saying is that India's dossier is credible bacause it extensively used material provided by the FBI. India has been saying since day one about the involvement of pakis. It is the americans who used our material to provide thier input not the other way round.
If CIA, KGB, MOSSAD, CBI
Mr. Milford you suggest what we should assume from Pakistan repeated denial mode on their involvement on Mubai attacks. It is quit transparent to the entire world the elements from Pakistan worked behind this attack and the same time Pakistan denying and challenging India instead of coming out with concrete step against those involved. If the official agency is not involved on this attack then why Pakistan canceled from sending ISI official to India. We are very proud to have Dr. Manmohan sigh as our prime minister as he is very calm and cool personality due to that only the region escaped from a War.
Why should india give importance to US statements ? Are we not powerful enough to portect our country and people ? Who need evidance that terrorists came from Pakistant and backed by ISI ?Guys, don't be silly... If you can't attack Pakistant, please keep quite atleast.. Did US ask for world to approve their attact against Iraq and Afgan ?
This fellow has two faces....they can do whatever they want and create an unstable situation in the world. Mulford is not the PM nor the gurdian of India. Press should not treat him as the authority to decide for us. I request Mr.Mulford to keep his mouth shut and behave as a guest nor as our gurdian. Our main problem is that slowly we are being sold to USA and our PM can not decide.
All hogwash from the Americans as usual. They did not take more tham 48-hours to begin bombing Afghanistan and go into Iraq (on false intelligence).
they r use to for false intelligence USA is bulling on world in all aspects but that is thr nature who will comment on thr stand no one except Israel thy do'nt bother abt USA
I dont think we have any reason to blame US. They attacked whosoever, because they had the guts and We did not attack all time troubling neighbour, because we did not have balls. It is as simple as that. I understand yours and everyone's feelings, since I too feel the same way, but, find myself embarrased to call myself a Proud Indian.
Mulford may have said that India's dossier is credible. But the US dossier is not credible as it speaks in different languages at different places. Instead of telling that Pakistan is a failed state and to make it a non-failed state, total over hauling of the system is necessary including that of its Army and also disbanding of its ISI, US officials sing different songs at different places. Their Asstt Secretary of State, Boucher who was bribed by Pakistan with an honorary award speaks in different voice at Pakistan and at India. So also our Prime Minister and other Ministers. They sing different tunes on different dates. And with this type of flip flop situation, nothing is going to happen. It will further strengthen the terrorists.
Well Mulford and USA are two face. Why our ministers must clarify with American what the terrorist has done in mumbai. Did USA come to us when they attack Afganistan. When USA will realise the day Pakistan is fooling them that is time they will declare them as terrorist state. Secondly the amount of money that Pakistan borrowed from American is till pending. So America do not think that Indian's are stupid we all know your tricks and that you are trying to fool the world.