www.expressindia.com - Weather | Horoscope | Stocks | RSS
expressindia web city
HomeBlogsCricketAstrologyShopping TendersClassifieds Opinions Hotels
Sign In / Register | Archive
Expressindia » Story

Patnaik wins trust vote, Gov seeks video footage

Font Size

Agencies

Posted: Mar 11, 2009 at 1713 hrs IST
Naveen patnaik and prakash karat

Bhubaneswar Orissa Chief Minister Naveen Patnaik on Wednesday won a trust motion by voice vote but Opposition leaders rejected the victory as 'manipulation' prompting Governor M C Bhandare to seek video recording of the proceedings of the special session of the assembly.

Bhandare asked the Speaker's office to furnish the video recordings shortly after leaders of opposition Congress and BJP walked out of the house and met him saying they wanted a division in the crucial trial of strength.

The two parties asked Bhandare to dismiss the government and recommend imposition of President's Rule.

Meanwhile, on the number of members who supported the motion, Speaker Kishore Mohanty said 81 MLAs in the 147-member house were present after the opposition walked out.

"The governor has asked us to furnish video records of the proceedings and also wanted to know if there is any past record about a trust motion being passed by voice vote," he said.

The trust motion, moved four days after withdrawal of BJP's support to the government following collapse of the BJD-BJP alliance over seat-sharing in the coming polls, was passed in barely two hours amid uproar, with Congress and BJP members storming the well.

Though the Speaker's office claimed that 81 members in support of the motion included BJD's 61, JMM's four, NCP's two, CPI's one and CPI-M's one besides seven Independents and five from BJP, including three who had quit recently, opposition leaders questioned its veracity.

Government Chief Whip Bikram Keshari Arukh also claimed that the motion was backed by 81 members.

The voice vote was taken up when opposition members were against the motion terming it as violative of the Model Code of Conduct as election dates had been declared.

Though Congress leaders rejected the voice vote as 'murder of democracy', some in the BJP camp claimed Congressmen allegedly created a situation deliberately to pave the way for passage of the motion by voice vote as part of 'a deal' with the ruling BJD.

"Indirectly Congress members helped BJD to sail through without even discussion on the trust motion," said a saffron leader requesting anonymity.

Refuting the charge, the chief minister said, "When the motion was put to vote, none sought division and it was passed by voice vote."

However, senior Congress member and former chief minister J B Patnaik said "we are totally dissatisfied in the manner in which the government won the trust vote."

Speaking in a similar vein, Congress deputy leader in the house Narsingh Mishra said "a trust vote is never conducted by voice vote. It is always recorded. Had there been proper voting, the government would have lost."

Dismissing Mishra's contention, BJD leader and Energy Minister S N Patra said "the opposition allegation is simply an afterthought".

Noisy scenes erupted in the house when the chief minister moved the motion and spoke on achievements of his government with the opposition terming it as violative of the Model Code of Conduct.

"As election dates had already been announced the trust motion is likely to influence the voters mind," Mishra said asking the speaker to convene a meeting of all political parties to discuss the matter before the motion was taken up.

"Is this house not being used to influence the voters" he said, demanding that the Patnaik's speech be examined and necessary portions expunged.

BJP members also trooped to the well demanding immediate disqualification of three MLAs who had recently resigned from their party.

Discuss this story on expressindia forums
Post Comments
Name* Email ID*
Subject* Country*
Message*
Characters remaining
 
TERMS OF USE: The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
Evil strategy by Ramakrishnan on 12 Mar 2009

Now Naveen Patnaik after shaking hands with Mr.Sitaram Yechury sitll says he is not out of the NDA in a very calculated move. He is now Pro-NDA, Pro-LEFT, and Pro-UPA. He wants votes of all parties - Oh ! what a strategy to fool the people of Orissa.

opportunistic scavengers by shyam kishore on 12 Mar 2009

Those who have opposed the minority oppression and violence against the Christians in Orissa under Naveen's rule has now join party with him . Shame on Left .they are nothing but an opportunistic scavengers

The Great Secular Card Blunder by Rajendra Gupta on 11 Mar 2009

Mr Patnaik !!what about the confidence vote of the people??

trust vote in orissa by sanjoy kumar satpathy on 11 Mar 2009

Now Mr Nabin Pattnaik wants to become a central minister with the help of CPM, which is not going to meterilise.Bad luck English speaking Odiya CM.You are the only chief minister in the world who can not speak nor under stand the mother tongue of the people whom you represent!!

Trust Vote by S.C. Aggarwal on 11 Mar 2009

Oh Naveen Babu you have won trust vote but with whom you are shaking hands? Be carefully and remain alert. These people are expert in welcoming but also expert in kicking. Any how o.k.. Good luck. Now you have become secular also.

Master Blunder by Yogesh on 11 Mar 2009

It's not a master stroke. It's a master blunder by Naveen Patnaik and the BJD. BJD has a vote share of 27% in Orissa. BJP has 17-18% and Congress gets 34-36%. CPI(M)'s vote share is 0.71%.Now Congress will sweep both Loksabha and Assembly elections. Both BJP and BJD will be losers. BJP's major loss will be in the Loksabha elections while Naveen's major loss will be in the Assembly elections.Naveen will regret after the election results.

opportunistis by shyam kishore on 11 Mar 2009

Those who raised the voice against Minority rights and Christian killing under Patnaik Government has joint force with him now . The left parties are nothing but opportunistic scavengers

Latest News

Business

Showbiz

Sports

India won’t accept legally binding emission cuts: Ramesh

Koda affect: ED raids realtor Emaar MGF's offices

Mumbai's water woes claim life as police cane protesters

Left to give PM 'evidence' of Maoist-Trinamool 'nexus'

ULFA ready for peace talks, says Rajkhowa

'True dialogue' isn't coupled with pre-conditions: Pak to India

25 years on, still waiting for Bhopal gas research

More
Featured Services
© 2009 The Indian Express Limited. All rights reserved
The Indian Express Group | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Work With Us | Site Map