www.expressindia.com - Weather | Horoscope | Stocks | RSS
expressindia web city
HomeBlogsCricketAstrologyShopping TendersClassifieds Opinions Hotels
Sign In / Register | Archive
Expressindia » Story

Varun says tape doctored, denies charge

Font Size

Agencies

Posted: Mar 17, 2009 at 2036 hrs IST

New Delhi Under attack from within and outside his party for his alleged anti-Muslim remarks, an unapologetic Varun Gandhi of the BJP refuted the charge he had made inflammatory comments and claimed that the tapes aired on TV channels in this regard appear to be doctored.

Gandhi (29), the BJP cadidate from Pilbhit for the Lok Sabha polls, said he was strongly committed to the ideals of secularism.

"I strongly refute the charge of making any communal or divisive statements as part of my election campaign. In this climate of terrorism, I have spoken only about standing firm against the anti-national and anti-social forces that threaten this nation," Gandhi said in a statement.

"I categorically reiterate my family's and my own unwavering commitment to the ideals of secularism," he said.

Gandhi blamed the controversy on his ‘frustrated electoral rivals’ for making ‘a crude and vicious attempt’ to malign him by doctoring his speech.

"I unequivocally state that that (the speech CD) is neither my voice nor my language. The tape in question appears to have been doctored," Gandhi claimed.

"These are purportedly two weeks old. None of what I have actually said was either intended or taken to be communal which is testified to by the fact that this intervening period there has been no communal tension or untoward incident," he said.

Discuss this story on expressindia forums
Post Comments
Name* Email ID*
Subject* Country*
Message*
Characters remaining
 
TERMS OF USE: The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
Varun Gandhi by Mohan on 30 Mar 2009

can any body throw some light on who recorded the speach? Did the Election Commission record any statement of the cameraman who recorded the tape?

IS HE WORTH DISCUSSING ??? by M.M.NAAZIM on 19 Mar 2009

MY FRIENDS !! WE INDIANS KNOW THE HISTORY OF VARUN'S FATHER SANJAY GANDHI WHO HAD THE REPUTATION AS DEMOLISHING MAN - TURKAMAN GATE EPISODE -- WHEN HE PERSONALLY SUPERVISED BULLDOZING THE PROPERTIES BELONGING TO MINORITY COMMUNITY IN DELHI'S CHANDNI CHOWK AREA , HE HAD SCANT RESPECT FOR HIS MOTHER INDIRA GANDHI , AN INDISCIPLINED SON ,,,,,,,,, NOW AFTER ALL VARUN IS HIS SON , SAME BLOOD ,,,, WHY SHOULD WE BE SURPRISED BY HIS VENOMOUS COMMENTS AGAINST MINORITIES ..... . JUST IGNORE HIM , AS HE IS NOT WORTH EVEN DISCUSSING . DONT WASTE TIME ON THESE TRIVIAL NONSENSICAL ISSUES

varun gandhi by keshav ranganath on 18 Mar 2009

Although it is believable that a tape could be doctored by rival parties, I hope it is true for Varun's and Sanjay Gandhi's family's sake. I have not followed Varun much, so I don't have an opinion about him. But I surely hope he is as worthy as his father.OK, trivia question: why did it take two weeks for the media to air this piece?

Dnt Apolige by mantar on 18 Mar 2009

We r poud u , dnt apolige for hwta u said.

doctoring tapes by n. anjaneya murthy on 18 Mar 2009

it has become a standard practice for rivals to doctor speeches of opponants during elections. even a mad candidate will now a days talk communal hatred and of all the people varun is incapable. it is therefore obvious that to eliminate varun from being a competetor to rahul, the techises of congress could have tampered the speech and created a cd. in case of doubt, the cd could be examined by scotlandyard experts.

Technology by sudhindra on 18 Mar 2009

using the current technology pictues and tapes can be manipulated. There is a need to check the authenticity before taking any action.

Possible Tape Doctoring by Rajan Shastri on 18 Mar 2009

There ought to be an investigation and if indeed the tape is doctored then the TV Channels should be sued for libel and defamation. If he is guilty, then he should be censured and asked to refrain from making such statement. Beyond that, let the public decide. There is a fine line between Freedom of Speech and making incendiary remarks.

Why not beleive Varun by Christo on 18 Mar 2009

Is he admitting having spoken those harsh words ? Now the entire english media is campaigning against the BJP and why not the CD be doctored. The whole nation watched Karunanidhi shouting when he was arrested by TN Police. His voice in that video was a dubbed one, made by Sun TV to gain sympathy. The media is trying to project it as a crime without even trying to verify the authenticity.

Secular Communalism by Alkesh on 18 Mar 2009

It is very hard to understand why media like you reproduce the Socalled communal remarks of the BJP or for that matter any Hindu leaders, and at the same time HIDE OR Conveniently Forgets to print OR Reproduce OR Slam the Sonia, Lalu, Arjunsingh, Amarsingh, Mulayamsingh brands of Pro-minority communal leaders when they go on bashing Hindus and appeasing minority? Let me say very clearly that more than the BJP or RSS, it is the media that damage the secular fabric of this country by SECULAR FANATICISM.

Varun by Chand on 18 Mar 2009

Secuarlists can defend terrorists, but won't let somenone speak his mind.Shame on you.

Wake Up varun, by Sadandava on 18 Mar 2009

Varun is playing the Hindutva card simply to enhance his chances of winning the Parliament seat. We wonder how much of Hindutva blood really runs in his vessels and veins? How much is he cross-bred? Be honest varun work for the good of India. Communal tensions may bring you a few more votes but mind you that you will have the blood of the innocent in your hands which you will not be able to wash easily. Do not bring shame and himilaiation to your forefathers who sacrificed their lives for the unity of India and secularism. You are in the wrong party for wrong reasons, try to get back to your originality and kill your ego, jealousy and vanity to become a genuine leader..

Wake Up varun, by Sunny on 18 Mar 2009

good one..hope he reads this.

Produce the Original please! by Ronald D'Souza on 18 Mar 2009

Varun should provide the original tapes (that are undoctored) he would have under the circumstances to prove his innocence. I am sure that he would have recorded the original speech for his own defence if needed like this or for his own review to improve upon his delivery if needed. I hope he's smart enough to realise that he cannot take India for a ride like this.

Prove undoctored by ASP Nayak on 18 Mar 2009

Instead prove that the CD is not doctored with. Those who provided the CD and the EC has to prove it is not fake.

Publicity Stunt by Dr.Harun Shaikh on 18 Mar 2009

It is commen that if any body want to be famous,he should make such a comment or statement so that people get aggravated,and as such you remain in the news,then say sorry you will not be punished,It is India's tradition.Varun Ghandhi has also done so because he is new in politics and He is trying to be "Narendra Modi".So nigther media nor people espescially Muslims should concentrate on this issue as it is mere publicity stunt.Nothing more than it.

POLITICAL EXCUSES by Niranjan on 18 Mar 2009

THIS IS A NEW EXCUSE. USUALLY THE DEFENCE IS ALWAYS: THIS IS A CONSPIRACY TO MALIGN ME AND MY PARTY. SO, NOW EVEN THE VIDEO-AUDIO PROOF IS NOT ACCEPTABLE TO POLITICIANS. NEXT TIME SOME ONE WILL MAKE AN EXCUSE THAT IT WAS A CLONE THAT SAID SUCH THINGS AND NOT HIMSELF!!

Varun Gandhi the BJP candidate by Avinash on 18 Mar 2009

It is quite appaling how over ambitious brats like Varun Gandhi are willing to causecommunal divide for their selfish political gains in the name of "Hinduvata". Let it be known that his very controversal and ambitious mother came from a Sikh family. Rather than misleading the world by swearing on Gita for political gains he should realise what he owes to Indian secularism ! Shame on his utterances !!!

Congress is "maut ka sauda" by Jatin Patel on 18 Mar 2009

The congress needs to explain the "maut ka sauda" with pakistan after charging Mr Narendra Modi. Aam aadmi had not seen any justice in form of actions taken by Ms Sonia Gandhi or for that sake any of her party member!

Liars and Politcs by salim on 18 Mar 2009

Indian politicians are typical liars you catch them on tape and they will still say it is liesSee what happed to Gujarat Tapes where a VHP/BJP minister confirmed on tape that he directed riots nothing hapes

Varun's Stand by IQUEBAL on 18 Mar 2009

APART FROM BEING A SADIST HATE MONGER THIS GUY IS ALSO A LIER. HE SHOULD NOW REALISE THAT THE PEOPLE LIKE HIM ARE A BURDEN ON ANY PROGRESSIVE SOCIETY LIKE INDIA. THATS WHY EVEN HIS OWN PARTY MEMBERS ARE STAYING AWAY FROM HIM. HE SHOULD BE CHARGED UNDER CRIMINAL OFFENCE AND AND PUT BEHIND BARS. HE DOES NOT DESERVE TO LIVE IN A DECENT SOCIETY.

kamal hai sahab by VInEET on 18 Mar 2009

indian, hindu, nationalism, love are all the words which smell of communalism and tolerance, peace, brotherhood are the words which lead us to a noble religion represented by talibs, maulanas, madrsas, antinational fugitives. what to say.cow slautering continues: varun is clear/ arms hoard: varun is clear/ now third allegation of 3 temples vandalized in his region: it can be checked and action be taken but all this pysdo secularists must not be given chance by cristian controlled media which is involved in all these doctored conspiracies to blame someone...

Mr.Varun Gandhi by VG Prabhakar on 18 Mar 2009

Ignore him. This is purely a cheap publicity gimmick. Voters are wiser than this person and will surely teach him a lesson. He had not been heard of for years and suddenly he comes to the fore with dirty speaking.

Liar by Ravi on 18 Mar 2009

Liar.How easily the politicians of sub continent tell lies.It is shame on us.I know BJP will support these type of hatared spreader

Islam stands for by SALI KAMAR on 18 Mar 2009

Dear Brothers and Sisters, Islam stands for monotheism. “Lalilaha Illallah” means - “There is none to be worshiped but Allah (God)”, which got nothing to do with Nazism. Islam does not encourage any devilishness.

problem by T.Jayaprakash on 20 Mar 2009

All the problem starts with that verse

Speak your mind openly without fear by Eddy on 17 Mar 2009

Dear Mr Gandhi there is no harm or shame in calling a spade, a "spade". Speak fearlessly and people will respect you. It is amply clear to one and all what Islam stands for. Like Nazism, this evil too will have to be defeated once and for all.

Care to elaborate? by vaibhava on 18 Mar 2009

Mr. Eddy or whatever your name is, care to elaborate what Islam stands for? You seem to be an authority on religion. Please enlighten us normal citizens. P.S. shame on you!

Care to elaborate ? by P L Selva Mani on 18 Mar 2009

Vai, Every one knows what Islam stands for . It is what every one claims to be fighting for that is the problem for Islam Yes, the Jihad. All acts are termed as Jihad against the Kafirs and justified . There are other terrorist groups but no one wears their religion on their sleeves like how the jihadis do Do you understand it now ?

Varun remrks by Sayed Jawhar Iqbal Rizvi on 18 Mar 2009

IT IS TO UNDERSTAND THAT VARUN WAS WELL TRAINED BY B.J.P TO DEMORALISE MINORITIES .THEY WANT TO CREATE COMMUNAL PROBLEM THROUGH HIM TO GET HINDU VOTE. DID HE KNOW WHO IS A REAL HINDU? WHO IS LOVING HIS NEIHBOUR, WHO RESPECT OTHER COMMUNITIES AND WHO IS LOVING THE HUMAN BEING. SO PLS LET HIM STUDY ABOUT HIS GRAND FATHERS HISTORY AND DONT BLAME ANY COMMUNITY BY FAMILY NAME. HE SHOULD BE TREATED FOR HIS MENTAL PROBLEMS AND U ARE A MISGUIDED AND SICK MAN EDDY.

varun is big treat to INDIA by ravi on 17 Mar 2009

IT IS UNDERSTAND THAT VARUN WAS WELL TRAINED BY B.J.P TO DEMORALISE MINORITIES .THEY WANT TO CREATE COMMUNAL PROBLEM THROUGH HIM TO GET HINDUS VOTE. DID HE KNOW WHO IS REAL HINDU?WHO IS LOVING HIS NEIBOUR,WHO RESPECT OTHER COMMUNITY AND WHO IS LOVING THE HUMANBEING. SO PLS LET HIM STUDY ABOUT HIS GRAND FATHERS HISTORY AND DONT BLAME ANY COMMUNITY BY FAMOUS BY FAMILY NAME. HE SHOULD BE TREATED FOR HIS MENTAL PEACE AND IT IS A BIG TREAT TO THE NATION

Anti muslim utterances by Jafar Zaidi on 17 Mar 2009

There is nothing new and surprising if a political leader utter anti muslim remarks from BJP platfarm which is their main plank during elections, therefore, should not be taken sriously.

Varun, Modi, Advani - different faces of frustrated fanaticsm by Naim Naqvi on 17 Mar 2009

A sad day indeed for Nehru - Gandhi dynasty ! This black sheep of the most secular family of India has reminded what Kabir Das had said - Dooba Vansh Kabir ka Jo upja poot Kamal." The soul of Pandit Jawahar Lal and Indraji must be wreathing in pain today. BJP had already squeezed the last drop of blood from Rama's name and, of course, it has miserably flopped in achieving its goal. Varun, the new face of fanaticism is not the disease per se but a symptom of disease that is blighting the forward march of secular India. Taliban may have failed to achieve success across the Muslim world but they have positively made a glittering success in producing the Talibans in RSS ranks. This young oaf, blockhead and dump brat of Mrs Manenka must be sent to reformatory as soon as possible. He is not fit to be allowed to sit in a decent society. This is the time that EC should show some grit and prove that it had some real teeth also. Mere notices are nothing but paper tigers.

Naim Naqwi: You hiot the nail on the middle of the head by irainesan on 18 Mar 2009

Mr.Naeem, yours is a superb, excellent and well written comment on the hypocrite, who has jumped into the wrong but the obnoxiously dirty band wagon simply because he has been brain washed to utter such non-senses thinking that, after all 1992 demolition of a place of worship brought the fanatics to power, and so why not commit ethnic cleansing of the minorities just before the elections to come to power. He is a dead force in india unless he realises his stupidity and re-baptized by his patriotic family.Keep commenting more oftern Naim.

Naim Naqvi: The Face of Fanaticism by Rohit on 18 Mar 2009

Naim Naqvi, Terrorism in today's world is there where there is a muslim... Be it India, Israel, US, UK, Thailand, Phillipine, Iraq, Sudan, Algeria, Australia, Indonesia AND your favorite countries... Pakistan, Bangladesh, Afghanistan. Terrorism is negligible in cse of non muslim community. Better think inwards before speaking

Latest News

Business

Showbiz

Sports

Pak anti-terror court declares Lakhvi as 26/11 mastermind

India-US sign six MoUs on counter-terrorism

Reveal files on the appointment of judges: CIC to SC

RR Patil refused to step out during 26/11: Bhujbal

ATR report an attempt to hush up Ayodhya issue: Maya

India indispensable to future we want to build: Obama

Time not right for pulling out Army: Omar

More
Featured Services
© 2009 The Indian Express Limited. All rights reserved
The Indian Express Group | Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Work With Us | Site Map