www.expressindia.com - Weather | Horoscope | Stocks | RSS
expressindia web city
HomeBlogsCricketAstrology TendersClassifieds Reader Comments Hotels
Sign In / Register | Archive
Expressindia » Story

You can't compare MNIK with 3 Idiots: Karan Johar

Font Size

BollywoodHungamaNewsNetwork

Posted: Feb 11, 2010 at 1201 hrs IST

Mumbai My Name Is Khan is just a few hours away from release and the obvious question that comes to mind is around the box office outcome of the film. With 3 Idiots setting such high standards at the box office and breaking the ceiling, doesn't it put an additional pressure on MNIK to perform further well?

It seems like this was the only ammunition that was waiting to find a way on the battlefield because Karan gets all fired up at this juncture. "I don't know why write-ups around one film taking a bigger opening than another or whether MNIK would be able to reach the highest slot when it comes box office openings keep appearing without any rhyme or reason. The kind of films that we are seeing today are all different from each other. Veer was different from 3 Idiots, just like My Name Is Khan is different from Veer. You can't be comparing a Guzaarish with a Kites. Or you can't be picking up a Raajneeti and start drawing comparisons with 3 Idiots. This is why I don't like the entire comparing business because all films are different from each other."

Calming down, he further goes on to extend his logic around difference in expectations that one must have when looking at two major films, "First and foremost we should be cognizant of the fact that comparing two entities never helps. A film should be allowed to breathe in the way it deserves to. Yes, now if only I would have made a film in a campus with students as my heroes then perhaps I may have compared it with 3 Idiots. But then just like you could never compare a Lagaan with a Dil Chahta Hai, similarly you can't ever compare MNIK with 3 Idiots or any other film."

Meanwhile, Karan is happy to be following the 'mantra' of making quality films without worrying much about their blockbuster fate.

"At Dharma Productions, we have great vibes amongst us", says Karan, "Everyone is quite passionate about filmmaking and we believe that we should always make films that we are proud of. Commercial success is important but not at the expense of something that would make us cringe later."

No wonder, most of the first time filmmakers working with Karan are happy to be working in an environment that challenges as well as motivates them to make something worth remembering.

"I never ask my directors to give me a film that would fetch me 80, 100 or 120 crores. Once you do that, you only end up putting pressure on the poor guy. Instead, I want them to focus entirely on the subject in front of them and leave the box office in the hands of audiences. This is what Ayan Mukerjee did with Wake Up Sid and look how he passed with flying colours both critically and commercially. Similar was the case with Rensil D'Souza who ensured that there is definite quality component to Kurbaan", concludes Karan with a tone of appreciation.

Discuss this story on expressindia forums
Post Comments
Name* Email ID*
Subject* Country*
Message*
Characters remaining
 
TERMS OF USE: The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.
MNIK by ahkaan on 20 Feb 2010

Mr. Karan, Please get a copy of Kannada daily Vijaya Karnataka of 20.2.10 and read Mr. Prathap Simha's column. If you donot know Kannada, get it read and translated by somebody. it is worth it. You being a great film maker I feel your strenth should be exhibited in making a movie for those suffering the terrorism in the name of Islam worldwide and especially in India

MNIK by Aryan on 17 Feb 2010

MNIK is certainly one of the greatest movies of Indian cinema.Agreed,its not as entertaining as 3 idiots but the theme demands it to be this way.I am sure all of us have had a ball of a time in college in criticizing the system which gets reflected in 3 idiots.9/11 is a serious issue.Very similar to Black,TZP.Thus Karan is extremely correct in asking us not to compare the two movies.

bEYOND cOMPARE by Shah P A on 17 Feb 2010

Totally unfair to compare these two movies. 3 Idiots had three idiots and MINK has just one stupid character. He should hve trudged his to Osama instead of the US President n given a lecture on terrorism. Mr. Khan would hve been eaten raw by Al Queda.

Dont compare by vishu on 13 Feb 2010

Yes, a brilliant movie like 3 idiots should not be compared with an idiotic movie - MNIK. Also, Karan can't break the collections at box office, so playing safe by asking us not to compare.

comments by saleem on 13 Feb 2010

mnik is one of the best movies made for many years, perhaps shivsena needs this type of film, which tells you cant stop spreading love, love has no boundaries, religion,culture,idealogies.

Great film by Gujarati on 16 Feb 2010

Great movie,Biggest blockbuster ever.Let these son of Thakrey bark!But we all know that ITS SRK=MEGA HIT!!

MNIK by Ashfak on 15 Feb 2010

This movie was boring and it failed to captivate. Hugely dissapointing and it can't be compared with 3 Idiots - it is on another level, beyond reach of MNIK.

Flop Movie by kumar on 12 Feb 2010

Karan, you are right. A boring movie like MNIK shouldn't be compared with 3 Idiots.

MNIK by subhakanta on 13 Feb 2010

I think u never love anyone in ur life,that's why u wrote like this.First love ur wife or ur girl friend,then u can only feel the the MNIK.

dude yur an idiot by vick on 19 Feb 2010

dude yur an !diot. what does MNIK has to do with havin a gf..hahahaha..yur too filmy and livin in a bubble.looks like you think that only yu hav a gf or wife..hahaha. movie suk a55 big time. controversies gave it a good start but monday tuesday wenzday and thursday, box office collections have fallen drastically.

Latest News

Business

Showbiz

Sports

No knowledge of threat to Rushdie's life: Maharashtra police

Is Modi fasting to atone for 2002 riots? Cong

BJP fielding Uma shows 'bankruptcy' of its leaders in UP: Digvijay

Team Anna advocating un-Gandhian law: Arundhati Roy

Teenager raped by two youth in UP

2G: Court reserves order on Swamy plea against PC till Feb 4

Priyanka Gandhi among 40 star campaigners of Congress in UP

More
© 2011 The Indian Express Limited. All rights reserved
Advertise With Us | Privacy Policy | Feedback | Express Group | Site Map